Licensed waste carrier CBDL398584 0161 818 7821 WhatsApp photos

Open research

What makes a rig fail?

As a responsible boat disposal company, we would like to learn more about rig failures. We re-home, sell and recycle old sailing boats, so the question of when standing rigging can no longer be trusted matters to us and to everyone who takes one of these boats on.

The usual advice is to replace standing rigging every ten to twelve years. We wanted to see the evidence, so we collected every documented failure we could find and check: accident investigations, race inquiries, surveyors' and riggers' write-ups, technical papers, magazines and owners' own accounts, in several languages.

The research is free. Everything on this page, and the full data behind it, is open to anyone, for the benefit of the sailing community.

Loading the database…

Download the full database (CSV)

If you are a rigger, or know one, please share your data

Riggers see what the published accounts leave out: how old the part was, who made it, when it was last inspected and what the break looked like. If you are a rigger, or know a rigger, please share your data with us so that we can improve this research. Surveyors and owners are just as welcome.

Send it in any form or shape. Job sheets, inspection reports, spreadsheets, photos, a list from memory, a few lines in an email: we can analyse it whatever it looks like. Please don't worry about preparing or tidying your data first.

Anonymous cases are welcome, and nothing is published with a customer's or a boat's name unless you ask for it.

Email info@boat-disposal.co.uk with the subject "Rig failure research".

Age of the failed part at the time of failure

Age is counted for the part that failed, in years. A boat re-rigged in 2019 whose 1985 chainplate breaks is recorded at the chainplate's age.

All events with a stated age

Boats racing at the time, or raced recently

The distribution has two humps, not one. Failures cluster in the first two years (new rigs and new boats) and again beyond 30 years. Every band in between, including the 10 to 15 year window that the usual replacement advice targets, holds far fewer cases.

The same ages, split nine ways

All panels in a breakdown share one vertical scale. Groups where no case states an age are left out; n is the number of cases with a stated age in that group.

Counts by age are not risk by age

Because owners are encouraged to replace rigs at about 10 to 12 years, few rigs older than that are sailing. A low count of old-rig failures could mean old rigs are safe, or simply that few exist. Two checks help tell these apart.

Failures that have nothing to do with age, as a control group

Installation errors, manufacturing and design defects and overload should strike rigs of any age, so their ages roughly mirror the ages of rigs at sea. Fatigue and corrosion failures can then be set against them.

Age-related cause: fatigue, corrosion, water ingress

Cause not related to age (the control)

Rig ages stated in used-boat listings

We sampled 567 used-boat listings from 13 sites, taking them in search order. Only 137 state the age of the rigging, and sellers mention rigging mainly when it is new, so the listings column understates the share of old rigs. A ratio above 1 means that age band appears more often among failures than among listed rigs.

Read with that bias in mind, rigs up to 15 years old appear less often among failures than among listed rigs, and the excess is in older rigs, above all those over 30 years. The size of that excess is overstated by an unknown amount, because the listings that say nothing about rigging almost certainly include most of the old rigs.

What the sources tell us, and what they leave out

Most accounts name the part that broke. Few give its age, and almost none name its maker or where it was made. Where a source does not state something, we left it blank and did not infer it.

Insurers and the ten-year rule

We also read published insurer statistics and the rigging clauses of 40 yacht insurance policies. We found no published dataset of rig failures by age behind the ten to twelve year advice. Few policies set an explicit age limit on standing rigging; more often, older rigs are covered at a reduced value, and failures put down to wear, corrosion or gradual deterioration are excluded. Failures of old rigs therefore often never become a paid claim, and so are missing from insurers' own figures.

All cases

No.YearBoatOutcomeFailed partCauseAge, yrRacedEvidence

Select a row for the full record and a link to its source. Evidence: A official investigation or laboratory analysis, B rigger or surveyor analysis, C first-hand owner account, D second-hand or news report.

How this was done, and its limits

Twelve groups of sources were searched separately. Every record was then checked against its source a second time, and anything the source does not state was removed. Reports of the same event from different sources were merged.

  • It is a sample of reported failures. A failure is written up when it is dramatic, instructive or happens in a race. Quiet failures are under-represented.
  • Age is stated selectively. Sources mention age when it is striking: brand new or very old. The middle of the range is probably under-recorded.
  • Cause is unknown in most cases, because no source gives one.
  • Some sources could not be read: paywalled magazines and sites that refuse automated access.
  • Some duplicates may remain among unnamed boats reported differently by different sources.
  • The inspection grouping is our own reading of what each account says.

A named boat, builder or manufacturer in a record means only that a published source named it. It is not a finding of fault. If you believe a record is wrong, email info@boat-disposal.co.uk and we will correct it.

Compiled November 2026.